“Stalinist architecture”: Reflected in modern research almost a hundred years later
EDN: WLGIQN
Abstract
The article provides a review of up-to-date academic knowledge of Soviet architecture of the 1930s–1950s, usually labeled in public discourse as Stalinist, as if the Soviet dictator was in fact its true supreme author. Of course, it is impossible to cover in one article the whole variety of problems associated with the study of the phenomenon of Stalinist architecture. For this reason, the author’s attention is focused on the most significant research trends. First of all, these include the search for the most appropriate terminology that would allow one to avoid excessive journalisticism (like the popular phrase “Stalinist Empire style”), would reflect the internal dynamics of the architectural process over the course of two decades, and would designate the place of Soviet architecture in the global context (primarily the Western one). From the point of view of methodology, the empirical approach still prevails, and the stage of identifying and systematizing the material is actually continuing. At the same time, the importance of microhistorical and biographical studies dedicated to specific regions and particular personalities is significantly increasing. Among a number of factors that negatively affect the research process, it is necessary to note the tendency towards politicization and re-ideologization of academic discourse in architectural history.
About the Author
I. Ε. Pechenkin
Russian State University for the Humanities
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Ilia Εvgen’ecich Pechenkin, Cand. Sci. (Art History) Head of the Department of Russian Art History, Faculty of History of Art
125047, Moscow, Miusskaya Sq., 6
References
1. Astrakhantseva, T. L. (2010). Stil’ velikoi epokhi [Style of the Great Epoch]. In T. L. Astrakhantseva (Ed.) Pobeda. Stil’ epokhi. 1945–1955: vystavka 7 maia — 15 sentiabria 2010 goda: Al’bom-katalog (pp. 9–22). Arsis-Dizain. (In Russian).
2. Astrakhantseva, T. L. (Ed.) (2023). Pobeda — stil’ epokhi: Akademicheskii vzgliad [Victory as the style of the era: Academic view]. Soiuz Dizain. (In Russian).
3. Avvakumov, Iu. I., Evstratova, M. V., & Koluzakov, S. V. (2023). Sochinil” arkhitektor’’ Shchusev’’ [Architect Shchusev composed]. Boslen. (In Russian).
4. Bagina, E., & Kapustin, P. (Eds.). (2019). Avangard, ar-deko, eklektika: Diskussionnyi klub PB [Avant-Garde, Art Deco, Eclecticism]. Proekt Baikal, 62, 30–36. (In Russian).
5. Bass, V. G. (2016). Arkhitektura dlia vnutrennego i naruzhnogo upotrebleniia: sovetskii pavil’on na n’iu-iorkskoi vystavke 1939 g. i ansambl’ VSKhV [Architecture for internal and external use: The Soviet pavilion at the 1939 New York World’s Fair and the All-Union Agricultural Exhibition]. Shagi / Steps, 2(1), 82–102. (In Russian).
6. Bass, V. (2016). Formal’nyi diskurs kak poslednee pribezhishche sovetskogo arkhitektora [The discourse of form as the last refuge of the Soviet architect]. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2016(1, no. 137), 16–38. (In Russian).
7. Brandenberger, D. (2002). National Bolshevism: Stalinist mass culture and the formation of modern Russian national identity, 1931–1956. Harvard Univ. Press.
8. Dobrenko, E. (1997). Formovka sovetskogo chitatelia: Sotsial’nye i esteticheskie predposylki retseptsii sovetskoi literatury [The making of the state reader: Social and aesthetic contexts of the reception of Soviet literature]. Akademicheskii proekt. (In Russian).
9. Dobrenko, E. (1999). Formovka sovetskogo pisatelia: Sotsial’nye i esteticheskie istoki sovetskoi literaturnoi kul’tury [The making of the state writer: Social and aesthetic origins of Soviet literary culture]. Akademicheskii proekt. (In Russian).
10. Dushkina, T. D. (2004). Vospominaniia o zhizni i tvorchestve arkhitektora Alekseia Nikolaevicha Dushkina [Memories of the life and work of the architect Alexei Nikolaevich Dushkin]. In N. O. Dushkina (Ed.). Zhizn’ arkhitektora Dushkina. 1904–1977: Kniga vospominanii (pp. 21–216). A-Fond. (In Russian).
11. Erofalov-Pilipchak, B. L. (2010). Arkhitektura sovetskogo Kieva [Architecture of Soviet Kyiv]. Izdatel’skii dom A+S. (In Russian).
12. Eigel’, I. Iu. (1978). Boris Iofan [Boris Iofan]. Stroiizdat. (In Russian).
13. Golomshtok, I. (1994). Totalitarnoe iskusstvo [Totalitarian art]. Galart. (In Russian).
14. Grois, B. (2023). Gesamtkunstwerk Stalin [Gesamtkunstwerk Stalin]. Ad Marginem Press. (In Russian).
15. Karpova, T. L. (Ed.) (2022). Aleksei Shchusev. Arkhitektor, khudozhnik, direktor: K 150-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia [Alexei Shchusev: Architect, artist, director: For the 150-anniversary of his birth]. Gosudarstvennaia Tret’iakovskaia galereia. (In Russian).
16. Kavtaradze, S. (1990). Khronotop kul’tury stalinizma [Chronotope of the culture of Stalinism]. Arkhitektura i stroitel’stvo Moskvy. 1990(11), 3–7. (In Russian).
17. Khan-Magomedov, S. O. (1996). Arkhitektura sovetskogo avangarda [Architecture of the Soviet Avant-garde] (Book 1). Stroiizdat. (In Russian).
18. Khan-Magomedov, S. O. (2010a). Ivan Zholtovskii [Ivan Zholtovsky]. S. E. Gordeev. (In Russian).
19. Khan-Magomedov S. O. (2010b). “Stalinskii ampir”: problemy, techeniia, mastera [“Stalinist Imperial style”: its problems, trends and architects]. In Iu. L. Kosenkova (Ed.). Arkhitektura stalinskoi epokhi: Opyt istoricheskogo osmysleniia (pp. 10–24). KomKniga. (In Russian).
20. Khan-Magomedov, S. O. (2011). Ivan Fomin [Ivan Fomin]. S. E. Gordeev. (In Russian).
21. Khmel’nitskii, D. (2007a). Arkhitektura Stalina: Psikhologiia i stil’ [Stalin’s architecture: Psychology and style]. Progress-Traditsiia. (In Russian).
22. Khmel’nitskii, D. (2007b). Zodchii Stalin [Stalin the architect]. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. (In Russian).
23. Khmel’nitskii, D. (2009). Vorovannyi vozdukh: o pol’ze arkhitekturno-istoricheskikh diskussii [Stolen air: on the benefits of architectural and historical discussions]. Proekt Klassika, 28. http://projectclassica.ru/discus/28_2009/28_discus_01.htm. (In Russian).
24. [Koluzakov, S.] (2017). Sergei Koluzakov: Mnogoe o Shchuseve v sovetskoe vremia prikhodilos’ zamalchivat’ [Much about Shchusev was necessarily suppressed in the Soviet epoch suppressed] (A. Spivak, Interviewer). Tret’iakovskaia galereia. https://www.tg-m.ru/news/sergei-koluzakov-mnogoe-o-shchuseve-v-sovetskoe-vremya-prikhodiloszamalchivat. (In Russian).
25. Konysheva, E. V. (2023). Mezhdunarodnye sviazi Soiuza sovetskikh arkhitektorov v 1930-e gody: professional’nyi dialog pod gosudarstvennym nadzorom [International relations of the Union of Soviet Architects in the 1930s: Professional dialogue under state supervision]. In A. G. Vyazemtseva, S. Gessler, K. A. Malich, & I. E. Pechenkin (Eds.). Boris Iofan. Puti arkhitektury 1920–1940-kh godov: K 130-letiiu arkhitektora (pp. 297–310). Kuchkovo pole Muzeon. (In Russian).
26. Kosenkova, Iu. L. (2010). Ot sostavitelia [Editorial note]. In Iu. L. Kosenkov (Ed.). Arkhitektura stalinskoi epokhi: Opyt istoricheskogo osmysleniia (pp. 7–8). (In Russian).
27. Kostyuk, M. (2019). Boris Iofan. Architect behind the Palace of the Soviets. DOM publishers.
28. Maciel Sanches, L. K. (2011). Tashkentskii opernyi teatr. “Natsional’noe” v tvorchestve A. V. Shchuseva [Tashkent Opera House. The “National” in the work of A. V. Shchusev]. In I. N. Sliun’kova (Ed.). Predmet arkhitektury: Iskusstvo bez granits (pp. 241–246). Progress-Traditsiia. (In Russian).
29. Malich, K. (2024). “Prishel, uvidel — pobezhden!” Sovetskie i britanskie arkhitektory v 1930–1960-e gody [“I came, I saw, I was defeated!” Soviet and British architects in the 1930s–1960s]. Muzei sovremennogo iskusstva “Garazh”. (In Russian).
30. Malinina, T. G. (2005). Formula stilia: Ar Deko: istoki, regional’nye varianty, osobennosti evoliutsii [Formula of style: Art Deco: origins, regional variations, features of evolution]. Pinakoteka. (In Russian).
31. Malinovskaia, E. G. (2016). “Repressirovannaia arkhitektura” — istoriia i problematika izucheniia, sud’by arkhitektorov (G. M. Liudvig, L. N. Meil’man) [“Repressed architecture” — history and problems of study, fate of architects (G. M. Ludwig, L. N. Mailman)]. Academia. Arkhitektura i stroitel’stvo, 2016(4), 55–64. (In Russian).
32. Malinovskaia, E. G. (2018). “Repressirovannaia arkhitektura” — stalinskie novostroiki, tvorchestvo i sud’by arkhitektorov [“Repressed architecture”: Stalin’s new buildings, creativity and fate of architects]. ARK Gallery. (In Russian).
33. Molok, N. (2023). David Arkin: “ideolog kosmopolitizma” v arkhitekture [David Arkin: “An ideologist of Cosmopolitanism” in the architecture]. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. (In Russian).
34. Orel’skaia, O. V. (2015). “Stil’ Pobedy” v arkhitekture goroda Gor’kogo [Victory Style in the architecture of the city of Gorky]. Kvarts. (In Russian).
35. Papernyi, V. (2007). Kul’tura Dva [Culture Two]. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. (In Russian).
36. Pechenkin, I. (2023). “Rusifikatsiia” sovetskoi arkhitektury v 1930–1940-kh gg.: ideologiia, teoriia, praktika [Russification of the Soviet architecture in 1930 and 1940s: ideology, theory, practice]. Rossiiskaia istoriia. 2023(2), 161–171. https://doi.org/10.31857/ S2949124X23020128. (In Russian).
37. Pechenkin, I., & Shurygina, O. (2018). Palladio po-russki. Novye dannye o perevode “Chetyrekh knig ob arkhitekture” v nachale XX veka [Palladio in Russian. News on the translation of the “Four Books of Architecture” in the beginning of 20th century]. Iskusstvoznanie. 2018(3), 238–263. (In Russian).
38. Pechenkin, I., & Shurygina, O. (2023). Ivan Zholtovskii: Opyt zhizneopisaniia sovetskogo arkhitektora [Ivan Zholtovsky: An attempt at a biography of the Soviet architect]. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. (In Russian).
39. Revzin, G. (2008). Sdvig po Khmel’nitskomu [Shift according to Khmelnitsky]. Proekt Klassika, 23, 186–188. (In Russian).
40. Sedov, Vl. V. (2022). Arkhitektor Boris Iofan [Boris Iofan, architect]. Kuchkovo pole Muzeon. (In Russian).
41. Selivanova, A. N. (2019). Postkonstruktivizm. Vlast’ i arkhitektura v 1930-e gody v SSSR [Postconstructivism: Power and architecture in USSR of the 1930s]. BuksMArt. (In Russian).
42. Shashkova, N. O. et al. (2023). Shchusev 150: Katalog vystavki [Shchusev 150: Exhibition catalog]. Gosudarstvennyi nauchno-issledovatel’skii muzei arkhitektury im. A. V. Shchuseva: Kuchkovo pole Muzeon. (In Russian).
43. Shchuko, V. A. (1935). Tvorcheskii otchet [Report on creative work]. Arkhitektura SSSR, 1935(6), 16–21. (In Russian).
44. Shirochin, S. (2020). Arkhitektura mezhvoennogo Kieva. Nesushchestvuiushchii gorod [Architecture of interwar Kyiv: Non-existent city]. Almaz. (In Russian).
45. Smolenskaia, S. A. (2023). Mezhdu modernizmom i sotsrealizmom: tvorcheskie sud’by ukrainskikh arkhitektorov [Between the Modernism and the Sotsial Realism: Artistic fate of Ukrainian architects]. In A. G. Vyazemtseva, S. Gessler, K. A. Malich, & I. E. Pechenkin (Eds.). Boris Iofan. Puti arkhitektury 1920–1940-kh godov: K 130-letiiu arkhitektora (pp. 182–195). Kuchkovo pole Muzeon. (In Russian).
46. Starostenko, Iu. D. (2023). Voprosy vzaimodeistviia arkhitektorov i vlasti na materialakh preobrazovanii proektnogo dela v Moskve v 1930-e gody [Problems of interaction of architects and the authorities. Based on the materials of the reformation of urban planning in Moscow in the 1930s]. In A. G. Vyazemtseva, S. Gessler, K. A. Malich, & I. E. Pechenkin (Eds.). Boris Iofan. Puti arkhitektury 1920–1940-kh godov: K 130-letiiu arkhitektora (pp. 148–158). Kuchkovo pole Muzeon. (In Russian).
47. Sudjic, D. (2022). Stalin’s architect: Power and survival in Moscow. Thames and Hudson.
48. Vyazemtseva, A. G., Gessler, S., Malich, K. A., & Pechenkin, I. E. (Eds.) (2023). Boris Iofan. Puti arkhitektury 1920–1940-kh godov. K 130-letiiu arkhitektora [Boris Iofan. The paths of architecture of the 1920–1940s: For 130 Years of the Architect]. Kuchkovo pole Muzeon. (In Russian).
Review
For citations:
Pechenkin I.Ε. “Stalinist architecture”: Reflected in modern research almost a hundred years later. Shagi / Steps. 2025;11(2):224–243. (In Russ.) EDN: WLGIQN
Views:
107
Email this article 