Taming the saint: Hilaria’s case
https://doi.org/10.22394/2412-9410-2022-8-4-194-207
Abstract
The legend of Hilaria belongs to a group of narratives about cross-dressing saints and tells the story of a fictional daughter of the Byzantine emperor Zeno: disguised as a man, she led a life of rigid asceticism among the monks of Scetis. Having emerged in the Coptic milieu (6th–7th centuries), the legend was translated into Syriac, Arabic and Ethiopic. The present article examines the changes undergone by the story in the process of rewriting, which might have been caused by translators’ and scribes’ ambivalent attitude towards the plot, given that they were mainly from a monastic society. Analysis of the Syriac version demonstrates that its author, who expanded the abridged redaction he had in his possession, borrowed some details from other, similar legends, in particular, from the Life of Euphrosyne, but he was also guided by the intention to “correct” the story of Hilaria in accordance with his conception of the ideal manly “holy woman”. Therefore, he made her older, more prepared for ascetic life both physically and spiritually, but chose to change the end of the legend by attaching a narrative, which exists in other stories about cross-dressing saints. Whereas in the Coptic version Hilaria’s stay in the monastery is sanctioned by the authority of abba Pambo, who becomes aware of her true sex through divine revelation, in the Syriac version he is completely absent, and his disappearance can be traced in Arabic redactions.
Keywords
St Hilaria,
St Euphrosyne,
cross-dressing,
transvestism,
gender,
translation,
Coptic hagiography,
Syriac hagiography
Supporting agencies: The project was supported by funding from the Mikhail Prokhorov Charitable Foundation (“Karamzin Scholarships: Internship at the School of Advanced Studies in the Humanities, RANEPA-2022”)
About the Author
L. L. Ermakova
The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Liia L. Ermakova, Cand. Sci. (Philology) Intern Researcher, Laboratory of Classical Studies, School of Advanced Studies in the Humanities
119571, Moscow, Prospekt Vernadskogo, 82
References
1. Anson, J. (1974). The female transvestite in early monasticism: The origin and development of a motif. Viator, 5, 1–32.
2. Castelli, E. (1991). ‘I will make Mary male:’ Pieties of the body and gender transformation of Christian women in Late Antiquity. In J. Epstein, & K. Straub (Eds). Body guards: The cultural politics of gender ambiguity (pp. 29–49). Routledge.
3. Constantinou, S. (2005). Female corporeal performances: Reading the body in Byzantine Passions and Lives of holy women. Uppsala Univ. Library.
4. Constantinou, S., & Høgel, C. (Eds.) (2021). Metaphrasis: A Byzantine concept of rewriting and its hagiographical products. Brill.
5. Davis, S. J. (2001). Crossed texts, crossed sex: Intertextuality and gender in early Christian legends of holy women disguised as men. Journal of Early Christian Studies, 10(1), 1–36.
6. Davis, S. J. (2015). From women’s piety to male devotion: Gender studies, the Acts of Paul and Thecla, and the evidence of an Arabic manuscript. Harvard Theological Review, 108(4), 579–593.
7. Delierneux, N. (1997). Virilité physique et sainteté féminine dans l’hagiographie orientale du IVe au VIIe siècle. Byzantion, 67(1), 179–243. (In French).
8. Esbroeck, M. van. (1991). Hilaria, saint. In Coptic Encyclopedia (Vol. 4, pp. 1230–1232). Macmillan Publ.
9. Haines-Eitzen, K. (2007). Engendering palimpsests: Reading the textual tradition of the Acts of Paul and Thecla. In W. Klingshirn, & L. Safran (Eds.). The early Christian book (pp. 177– 193). Catholic Univ. of America Press.
10. Lubinsky, C. L. (2013). Removing masculine layers to reveal a holy womanhood: The female transvestite monks of late antique Eastern Christianity. Brepols.
11. Patlagean, E. (1976). L’histoire de la femme déguisée en moine et l’évolution de la sainteté feminine à Byzance. Studi Medievali, ser. 3, 17(2), 597–623. (In French).
12. Ruani, F. (2022). Thecla beyond Thecla: Secondary characters in Syriac hagiography. In G. Dabiri, & F. Ruani (Eds.). Thecla and medieval sainthood: The Acts of Paul and Thecla in Eastern and Western hagiography (pp. 142–174). Cambridge Univ. Press.
13. Staat, K. (2022). Reception and rejection: Thecla and the other Acts of Paul and Thecla in the Passion of Eugenia and other Latin texts. In G. Dabiri, & F. Ruani (Eds.). Thecla and Medieval sainthood: The Acts of Paul and Thecla in Eastern and Western hagiography (pp. 256–281). Cambridge Univ. Press.
14. Voytenko, A. A. (2004). Imperator i imperatorskie rodstvenniki v Zhitiiakh apy Kira i blazhennoi Ilarii: k voprosu o tak nazyvaemom koptskom natsionalizme v V–VII vv. [The emperor and emperor’s relatives in the Lives of Apa Cyrus and Blessed Hilaria: To the question of socalled Coptic nationalism of the 5th–7th centuries]. In Tezisy dokladov XVII Vserossiiskoi nauchnoi sessii vizantinistov: Vizantiia i Zapad (pp. 38–43). Institut vseobshchei istorii RAN. (In Russian).
15. Wilfong, T. (1997). Reading the disjointed body in Coptic: From physical modification to textual fragmentation. In D. Montserrat (Ed.). Changing bodies, changing meanings: Studies on the human body in Antiquity (pp. 116–136). Routledge.
Review
For citations:
Ermakova L.L. Taming the saint: Hilaria’s case. Shagi / Steps. 2022;8(4):194-207. https://doi.org/10.22394/2412-9410-2022-8-4-194-207
Views:
57
Email this article 